ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
Date: May 26, 1999
Author/Local: M. Crocker/7647RTS No. 640
CC File No. 1188
Council: June 15, 1999
TO:
Vancouver City Council
FROM:
Chief Information Officer and City Clerk
SUBJECT:
Increasing Use of Internet Technology:
The Need for a Corporate Internet WebmasterRECOMMENDATION
THAT Council approve the establishment of one new regular full-time position of Corporate Internet Webmaster at an estimated annual cost of $55,000, subject to classification by the General Manager of Human Resource Services; source of funding to be re-allocation within the Information Technology operating budget.
GENERAL MANAGER'S COMMENTS
The General Manager of Corporate Services RECOMMENDS approval of the foregoing.
COUNCIL POLICY
On June 19, 1990, Council established 'information' as one of the City's corporate priorities.
In the Better City Government initiatives of 1994 and 1995, Council endorsed a work program that identified Technology and Communications as key supporting strategies.
City Council approves the establishment of new positions and has directed, whenever possible, that they be funded from existing budgets.
Council has instructed that departments requesting program or staffing increases identify expenditure reductions or revenue enhancements that fully offset the incremental cost to the Operating Budget.
BACKGROUND
In 1995, Council approved $90,000 for the implementation of Internet technology and the creation of a City presence on the World Wide Web. Global use of this technology and the City's website have both flourished.
The City's (public) Internet website provides:
· Information on municipal services;
· Distribution of City reports (it is the prime means of distributing the council package to the public);
· Explanation of key issues affecting the quality of life in Vancouver;
· A window on the democratic process;
· Access to elected officials and staff;· Links to relevant websites containing information on areas outside the City's jurisdiction, like tourism and services provided by other levels of government;
· A quick way for the public to find information and resources through self service and powerful search capabilities.Highlights and acclamations accorded to the site are listed in Appendix A, which also lists key usage statistics, including the fact that the site offers over 20,000 pages of information and serves 2,500 customers a day - with the majority of requests coming outside of regular working hours. This is outreach on a scale difficult to achieve through traditional information distribution. It allows a public, who might not access City information otherwise, to serve themselves with information unique to their needs or interests.
The City's (private) Intranet provides staff with:
· Easy and quick access to a wide variety of information resources and administrative tools, both internal and external, that help staff respond effectively to service requests and more efficiently carry out their daily work;
· Communications facilities, through the web, e-mail and newsgroups, for various cross-departmental groups;
· Daily updates on training opportunities, staff moves, organizational changes, Fit City events, awards and recognitions, furthering internal communication and helping to foster a sense of community.
Highlights are listed in Appendix A.
All departments recognize the value of the technology and contribute to the website. Several have assigned responsibility for their information to a staff member, on either a full or part-time basis, as "Internet coordinator". This departmental information ownership works very well.
Like most government organizations, the City justifies its (relatively small) investment in Internet technology primarily through improved services to the public. However, while it is difficult to prove a direct cause-and-effect relationship, a reduction in photocopying, paper and printing costs is evident. It is also reasonable to believe that the City's website relieves the inquiry load on staff, and that the site contributes positively to the Vancouver economy through support for tourism and business investment.
An example of the impact that this service can have from an operational and policy perspective is the City Pound. This site, with pictures of dogs available for adoption, is one of our most popular sites. Since the site went into operation, there has been a significant increase in dog adoptions, believed to be in large part due to the site. This increase in the adoption rate has helped the Pound meet the objective of the recent no-kill policy.
It should be noted that the Internet and (especially) intranet services are being used as administrative tools for the regular work of staff, as opposed to the popular entertainment image that the Internet conjures up.
DISCUSSION
Success has brought challenges. The volume of information and our dependence on it demand active management: ensuring that information remains current, repairing broken links to other documents and sites, maintaining a consistent look for ease of use, identifying and pursuing new service opportunities, and analysing the site's use, effectiveness and design. The rate of technological change requires that hardware and software upgrades be performed regularly. The rate of innovation and the growth of customer expectations demand constant monitoring of technology trends, and research into new tools and technologies. Within the City, policies, standards and procedures must adapt rapidly to these changes.
Although the website is having a growing influence in shaping public perceptions of the organization, tese are more than just cosmetic issues. People depend on the website - for example, for the Council package and decisions - and are quick to complain when it is unavailable, when it is slow, or when their information needs are not met.
Challenges like these have prompted organizations to create the role of "webmaster" to manage their site. Depending on the organizational structure and size, this role may encompass responsibility for some or all of technology implementation and management, information content, presentation, communications policy, and corporate image.
The webmaster position recommended in this report will provide the interface between the City Clerk's Corporate Communications Office, which has overall responsibility for corporate communications policy and specific responsibility for media relations, and the departmental Internet coordinators, who provide service-related information. Responsibilities involve both reliability and quality of the service and will be (more detail is provided in Appendix B).
· Hardware and software maintenance and support, ensuring that the site is available 24 hours a day, seven days a week;
· Security administration for access control and confidentiality of information;
· Management of information structure and quality control;
· Development and application of usability standards;
· Assistance to others with web pages and applications.A website should leave the user feeling rewarded and encouraged to return. Information must be easy to find, complete, current, quick to download (many users reach the site through relatively slow modems), and have a look and feel that are consistent and pleasing. For a large and diverse site like the City's, maintained by a number of different people, this demands coordination, site management utilities, and standards. The Corporate Communications Office sets the tone and communication goals for the website; the webmaster translates them into a structure that allows individual information providers to contribute and create a harmonious whole. The webmaster is responsible for the overall quality of service.
A staff member has been seconded to this role on a temporary basis for six months, making considerable progress during that time, and confirming the need for a permanent position.
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPLICATIONS
While there is no direct environmental impact, the overall environmental implications of electronic delivery of information and services are positive, through reduction of both paper use and visits to City Hall.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
While new positions are subject to evaluation by the General Manager of Human Resources, we anticipate that the position will be classified at PG 24, for which the annual cost including fringe benefits and an allowance for appropriate computer equipment is $55,000.
The proposed source of funding is the microcomputer maintenance component of the Information Technology Corporate Support budget. Annual hardware maintenance for the City's inventory of 3,000+ microcomputers is budgeted at $566,000. The webmaster position can be funded by a $55,000 re-allocation of this budget, made possible because the oldest and most non-standard components of the City's microcomputer inventory have been replaced over the last two years and the maintenance contract can be re-negotiated to reflect this. The negative impact on operational efficiency will be minimal, and far outweighed by the positive impact on service to the public.
CONCLUSION
The City's website is a recognized leader in the depth of information it offers. With further development and the widening use of the Internet in homes, offices and public places, it promises real extensions to traditional service delivery offerings and new opportunities for public participation and involvement in the process of government.
A Corporate Internet Webmaster can help to ensure that these opportunities are captured, and that the growing number of people who use the City's website every day will be rewarded with quality service.
* * * * *
APPENDIX A
City Website and Intranet - Highlights and Usage
Public Website:
· The website has set a high standard for quality, won the 1997 UBCM award for best BC municipal website, and was recognized by the Vancouver Sun in 1998, as a "hot" site;
· The website has become the primary means of distributing the Council meeting package and minutes to elected officials, public, media and staff;
· Quickfind, a directory of staff and services, received the 1998 Municipal Information Systems Association (MISA) "Spirit of Innovation" award;
· The City Pound "dog adoption" pages are visited by 50 to 100 people a day, and adoptions are up by 160% over the comparable pre-web period last year;
· An option to pay parking tickets on-line will be available in early June, 1999;
· Records, including photographs, from the City Archives will available for browsing in early June, 1999. Customers will be able to order photographs on-line;
· It is proposed that the City web server host the Vancouver Millennium web site, starting around September, 1999;
· Key statistics with interpretive comments italicised:
· Number of pages on entire site 20,000
· Number of "hits" (daily average) 49,000
"Hits" are file accesses - an often-quoted but relatively meaningless figure.
· Number of web pages viewed (daily average) 12,000
· Number of person visits (daily average) 2,500
· Percentage of weekday use outside of 8:30am - 5:30pm work hours 45%
· Percentage of total use occurring at weekends 21%
Percentage of total use that occurs outside of working hours - 57%
· Percentage of use originating in Canada 34%
Underestimate, because many locally-used ISP's are located in US - e.g. AOL
· Percentage of use originating outside North America 7%
(5 leading countries: UK, Germany, Australia, Japan, Switzerland)
· Average time a customer spends looking at website 11 minutes
· Most frequently-requested single pages:
Jobs (several pages, different areas) Quickfind directory search
About Vancouver Transportation
City Pound adoptions Police - Human Resources
Getting In Touch (with elected officials & staff) Planning and Land Use
Tourist Attractions in Vancouver Vancouver Maps
Current Council Agendas, Minutes and Reports Police - Dog Squad
Vancouver A-to-Z What's New at the City of Vancouver
Appendix A - Page 2
City Website and Intranet - Highlights and Usage (Cont'd)
Intranet:
· The intranet ("Citywire") is accessible to around 3,000 staff, providing access to a wide range of information and a growing number of information systems, including:
· License+, the business license system;
· maps of the city, derived from the digital mapping / GIS system;
· the City Council Report Tracking System (RTS);
· Quickfind;
· A system for tracking address-related activity by Neighbourhood Integrated Service Teams (NIST);
· MainSaver, which lets staff submit facility-related service requests on-line;
· Extended help for the SAP financial and human resource systems.
· Key statistics:
· Number of pages on entire site 4,000
· Number of web pages viewed (daily average) 15,000
· Number of staff visits (daily average) 800
Role:
To work closely with the Corporate Communications Office, providing content coordination and technical support for the maintenance and further development of the City's public and internal web sites as key components of its communication and service delivery strategy.
Responsibilities:
Hardware and Software Maintenance and Support:
· Install, configure & maintain software on Internet servers;
· Develop operational procedures to ensure data protection & site availability;
· Administer or support the administration of web servers, news and POP mail servers.
Security Administration:
· Maintain userids and passwords as needed for appropriate access control;
· Ensure that confidentiality of customer information is maintained;
· Provide input into the administration of the firewall (proxies, rules, policies).
Management of Information Structure and Quality Control:
· Maintain top-level pages (home page links, menu, "What's New", etc.), in consultation with the Corporate Communications Office;
· Maintain overall information structure and navigational consistency;
· Minimize information overlap with the VPL website, and seek out opportunities for collaboration and cross-referencing;
· Provide quality assurance (monitor broken links & report them to departmental coordinators, review error logs, follow up on stale information);
· Monitor & analyse usage (hits/page), provide feedback to departmental coordinators.
Development and Application of Usability Standards:
· Chair the Internet coordinator meetings, advise the Web Management Working Group;
· Maintain an awareness of and have direct input into changes and new developments on the City's website;
· Through a consultative and inclusive process, develop and maintain necessary web style standards and guidelines, provide education to encourage compliance.
Assistance to Others with Web Pages and Applications:
· Support web page developers & Help Desk staff with Internet technologies;
· Support implementation of in-house developed or purchased web-based applications;
· Provide web page design and consulting services to staff throughout the City;
· Evaluate HTML editors, conversion and site management software;
· Assist departmental content providers in finding appropriate staff training or external page development resources, as needed to deliver their information to the website.
* * * * *
(c) 1998 City of Vancouver