ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
Date: July 14, 1997
Dept. File No. CREP 080.wpd
CC File: 1805
TO: Vancouver City Council
FROM: General Manager of Engineering Services
Manager of Purchasing Services
SUBJECT: Award of Tender No. 54-97-01: Supply of Parking Meters
RECOMMENDATION
THAT Council accept the bid from Trafco (Canada) for the supply of
250 Mackay model MKV 97-2HD c/w Guardian mechanisms, complete twin
electronic parking meters, 100 Mackay model MKV 97HD c/w Guardian
mechanisms, complete single electronic parking meters, 1001 Mackay
Guardian fully electronic mechanisms and 600 card slot with smart
card reader options, at a total purchase price of $467,742.24 plus
the Provincial Sales Tax, subject to a contract satisfactory to the
Director of Legal Services.
COUNCIL POLICY
The policy of Council is to award contracts for the purchase of
equipment, supplies and services that will give the highest values based
on quality, service and price.
Contracts with a value over $300,000 are referred to Council.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
The funding for the complete twin and single electronic parking meters
is subject to Council approval of the costs as described in the Parking
Meter Program Review Report. The purchase of the meter mechanisms has
been approved by Council with $180,000 provided from Supplementary
Capital and $60,000 from the Parking Meter Depreciation Fund.
DISCUSSION
Tenders for the above were opened on July 02, 1997 and referred to the
General Manager of Engineering Services and the Manager of Purchasing
Services for report. The Provincial Sales Tax is in addition to all
prices shown in this report and in the tabulation. The Goods & Services
Tax is net 0% for parking meter purchases.
The tender requested prices for complete twin and single electronic
parking meters, fully electronic parking meter mechanisms and various
optional items. A special discount is also requested if this contract
is awarded in its entirety to a single contractor.
Engineering Services recommends that 250 complete twin electronic meters
including card slot with smart card reader options (Item 1), 100
complete single electronic meters including card slot with smart card
reader options (Item 2) and, 1001 fully electronic meter mechanisms
(Item 3) be purchased for this tender.
Three suppliers submitted bids.
Items 1 and 2
Trafco (Canada) is the low bid for both items and is recommended.
Item 3
Interprovincial Traffic Services is the low bid, but it is not
recommended as their offered sample mechanism does not adequately
discriminate coins from inappropriate coins or objects such as washer,
slug or foreign coins as specified. In addition, their bid does not
comply with the liquidated damages and payment clauses as specified in
our special conditions.
Trafco (Canada) is the second low bid when the special discount is taken
into consideration, meets specifications and is recommended.
The Mackay parking meters offered by Trafco (Canada) also have several
advantages:
- meters have an indiglo light that illuminates the display in
low light situations. This will be an advantage for the
extended meter hours in the evening.
- meter mechanisms have a 24 month warranty period instead of 12
months offered by the other two brands.
- meter mechanisms have the best fit in the various housing used
by the City.
- the City already has a hand held microcomputer unit to
reprogram and audit the existing Mackay meters that can also
be used for the recommended new Mackay meter purchase.
We are, therefore, recommending acceptance of the bid from Trafco
(Canada) for the supply of two hundred and fifty (250) Mackay model MKV
97-2HD c/w Guardian mechanisms, complete twin electronic parking meters,
at a purchase price of $213,517.50 ($840.35 each plus $6.86 each for 500
card slot with smart card option), one hundred (100) Mackay model MKV
97HD c/w Guardian mechanisms, complete single electronic parking meters,
at a purchase price of $45,276.00 ($445.90 each plus $6.86 each for card
slot with smart card option), and one thousand and one (1001) Mackay
Guardian fully electronic mechanisms at a purchase price of $208,948.74.
($208.74 each).
* * * * *