SUPPORTS ITEM NO. 2 T&T COMMITTEE AGENDA JUNE 3, 1997 ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT Date: 20 May 1997 Dept. File No. 4252-10 CC File No.: 8111/5554-1 TO: Standing Committee on Transportation and Traffic FROM: General Manager of Engineering Services SUBJECT: West End Transit Service RECOMMENDATION A. THAT the proposed new #5 Robson/Downtown and #6 Davie/ Waterfront transit routes, as illustrated in Appendix C, be approved. B. THAT BC Transit be requested to investigate as a high priority the potential for moving the termini for the West End transit services from Denman and Davie Streets to the eastern Entertainment District in order to provide a continuous transit connection between the Davie, Denman and Robson Street commercial/residential neighbourhoods, as illustrated in Appendix E. C. THAT staff report back on new bus stops, shelters, litter containers, landing improvements and other details of route implementation as necessary. COUNCIL POLICY - Council has established public transit as a high priority. - Council supports measures to increase transit use as a means of reducing the impacts of general vehicular traffic growth and improving regional air quality, as per the Transport 2021 initiatives and Draft Transportation Plan. - Council approves transit routes and bus stops locations on City streets. PURPOSE BC Transit will be implementing a revised West End transit service on September 1, 1997. This report recommends approval of the proposed route. BACKGROUND The City has for many years requested that West End transit services be separated from the Main and Fraser Street services. The services are currently combined, as illustrated in Appendix A. Advantages to separating the West End services include: - Improved service reliability. Separating the services would shorten the existing routes and isolate service problems in the West End or on Main and Fraser Streets. These service problems can be more easily dealt with and therefore service reliability would increase. West End routes are already separated from the Main Street and Fraser Street services in the evenings, Sundays and holidays, primarily in order to deal with delays caused by congestion on Robson Street. - Enhanced service frequencies Separating the routes would make it easier to implement service frequencies designed specifically for the West End, independent of changes to the Fraser and Main Street services. Service frequencies could be more closely matched to ridership. - Lower fares A separate West End service could make it easier for BC Transit to implement lower transit fares in the downtown in future, as requested by Council. On June 21, 1990 Council requested BC Transit introduce a separated West End route as illustrated in Appendix B. On June 29, 1997, the Vancouver Regional Transit Commission approved BC Transit s plan to introduce a separate West End service in September 1997. PUBLIC WORKSHOP On April 21, 1997, BC Transit hosted a public workshop at the Vancouver Public Library regarding proposed new downtown transit services. Thirty-one people attended, including City staff. There was general agreement on the concept of a separate West End service. Other comments included the need for improved frequencies, less crowding and direct connections to other components of the transit network, especially to SkyTrain. PROPOSED SERVICE Based on input from the workshop, a new service plan was developed and presented to the City on May 20, 1997. As illustrated in Appendix C, BC Transit is proposing no change to the existing routes in the West End, west of Granville Street. The termini would remain at Davie and Denman Streets. However, east of Granville Street, the routes would turn around at Waterfront Station and at Library Square, rather than continue on to Main and Fraser Streets. Service frequencies would be improved. As described in Appendix D, the most significant improvements would occur in the midday (from about 8.5 to 7 minutes) and evenings (from 15 to 10 minutes). The public process and proposed routes are described in more detail in a BC Transit report (available in the City Clerk s office) entitled "Downtown Vancouver Transit Enhancement Phase II - West End to Downtown". DISCUSSION BC Transit s proposal would achieve the benefits of a separated service. Reliability would be improved and a service connection would be provided to the Entertainment District and Library Square. However, there is still a need to improve internal West End transit service. At present, West End transit routes effectively discontinue at the Davie and Denman Street termini. Buses terminate for up to 10 minutes and transit passengers may be required to get off the bus when it is stopped. As a result, transit customers can not make efficient transit trips between the Denman/Robson and Davie Street commercial/residential neighbour-hoods. It would be desirable to relocate the Denman Street and Davie Street termini to the Entertainment District in future, as illustrated in Appendix E. This would create a continuous internal West End transit link. In addition to the travel benefits to West End transit customers, there would likely be less automobile use for internal West End trips, and the noise and visual concerns at the current Davie Street and Denman Street termini would be reduced. BC Transit has identified this as a potential future option. It is recommended that BC Transit investigate the proposal in detail as a high priority City request. MAIN AND FRASER STREET SERVICES New routes would have to be developed for the #3 Main and #8 Fraser services in the downtown, since they would no longer be connected to the West End services. The preference would be for these routes to extend as far west as the Golden Triangle. The proposed routes will be reported to Council for approval when finalized. CONCLUSION It is recommended that Council approve the proposed new West End transit routes in order to improve service frequency and reliability, and provide a new transit connection to the Entertainment/Library District. Staff will report back on new bus stops and other details regarding route implementation, as necessary. Service levels and ridership will be monitored when the service is introduced. Staff will work with BC Transit on the proposal to create a continuous West End service with an eastern termini. * * * * * APPENDIX D WEST END TRANSIT SERVICE FREQUENCY COMPARISON TIME PERIODS EXISTING FREQUENCY PROPOSED FREQUENCY (MINUTES) (MINUTES) AM PEAK 6-7 6 MIDDAY 8-9 7 PM PEAK 5-6 5-6 EVENING 15 10 NIGHT 15 15 SATURDAY BASE 6-10 7 SUNDAY/HOLIDAYS 10 10