A12
ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
Date: March 13, 1997
C.C. File: 3139-1
TO: Vancouver City Council
FROM: City Manager
SUBJECT: Local Government Interests in Lower Mainland Area Treaty
Organizations
RECOMMENDATION
A. THAT Council receive the attached report on Lower Mainland
Area Treaty Organizations for information.
B. THAT Council's feedback and support on the document be
channelled through Council s representative to the Lower
Mainland Treaty Advisory Committee (LMTAC).
CITY MANAGER S COMMENTS
The City Manager RECOMMENDS approval of A & B.
COUNCIL POLICY
On March 14, 1995, City Council endorsed the following principals and
rights formulated by the Province, that will be used to guide the
Provincial negotiation teams on First Nations land claims:
- Private property will not be on the table;
- Access to land and resources for hunting, fishing and recreational
use will be guaranteed;
- The Canadian Constitution and Charter of Rights and Freedoms will
be applied to all citizens of British Columbia;
- Agreements must be affordable to B.C. taxpayers;
- The Federal Government's primary constitutional and financial
responsibility for treaties must be maintained.
- Fair compensation for unavoidable disruption of commercial
interests will be assured;
- Jurisdictional certainty between First Nations and municipalities
must be clearly spelled out;
- Province wide standards of resource management and environmental
protection will apply.
In addition, Council identified the following City concerns, which were
communicated to the Federal and Provincial Governments:
- Real property owned by a municipality should not be at risk;
- Real property held by a municipality under long-term leases and/or
trustee agreements from either level of senior government should
not be at risk;
- Real property owned/held by First Nations outside the official
boundaries of their Reserves not be granted Reserve status. These
properties, if they fall within the official boundaries of a
municipality, are to be treated like any other private property
with respect to taxation and application and enforcement of
municipal by-laws;
- The application and enforcement of municipal by-laws are to include
all First Nations Reserve properties that fall within the official
boundaries of a municipality.
BACKGROUND
The LMTAC is comprised of representatives from 26 jurisdictions from the
Lower Mainland area who have been collaborating on the municipal
interests in Treaty negotiations since 1994. Councillor Nancy
A.Chiavario has been Council s representative on the LMTAC from the
onset and is currently the Chair of LMTAC. The LMTAC, through three
separate efforts - an interest paper, a half day workshop, followed by a
full day facilitated working session, has brought forward an agreed upon
set of principles to guide municipal participation in negotiations as
outlined in the attached report (Appendix I).
DISCUSSION
The purpose of the attached report is to provide LMTAC members with a
reference that guides the interests of the local government members in
negotiations. It will also be used to provide Federal, Provincial and
Aboriginal negotiators with an initial understanding of the viewpoints
and interests of area local governments. It is intended that the
document is dynamic; that is, changing and evolving as negotiations
progress. Once feedback is provided by Councils to the LMTAC, the
document will be brought back to Council for final endorsement. More
detailed and community-specific information will be added as
negotiations enter substantive phases. Appendix II contains January and
February bulletins outlining the current activities of LMTAC
The report identifies:
- interests in the negotiation process - this section provides a
summary of the Committee s interests related to the process of
negotiating treaties and Local Governments participation therein;
- general interests in negotiating settlements - this section cover
Committee members general interests or principles they wish
reflected in any negotiated settlements;
- issue-specific interests in negotiating settlements - this section
is a preliminary listing of guiding principles the Committee has
formulated related to services and issues in which Local Government
has a direct interest.
In summary, the Committee believes that any negotiated settlements
should assist all citizens of British Columbia to live in harmony with
each other by understanding and respecting each other s values, race,
heritage and place of origin. The Committee also believes each citizen
of the Province should be treated equally and have similar rights and
responsibilities. The Committee recognizes that to accomplish these
aims within negotiated settlements will be a challenging task. However,
to settle for less would not serve the aims of the treaty negotiation
process, nor would it be just to the citizens of British Columbia -
aboriginal and non-aboriginal.
SUMMARY
The participation of elected officials and staff on the LMTAC will help
to achieve successful negotiations in treaty discussions. More detailed
and community-specific information will be required as negotiations
progress. Input from Council will be sought as the treaty negotiations
progress.
* * * * *