ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
Date: June 13, 1996
Dept. File No. 3213
TO: Vancouver City Council
FROM: Manager of the Housing Centre
SUBJECT: Assignment of Long-Term Leases - 1878 Robson Street
RECOMMENDATION
THAT Council, amend By-law No 6774, and, in accordance with Section
2(3) of the Residential Tenancy Act, to delete the approval for the
single apartment and substitute a provision to permit the Belmanor
Apartments Limited to enter into and assign long-term leases for
all the units at 1878 Robson Street and instruct the Director of
Legal Services to bring forward the necessary by-law.
GENERAL MANAGER'S COMMENTS
The General Manager of Community Services RECOMMENDS approval of
the foregoing.
COUNCIL POLICY
Council policy is to protect the interest of tenants in any loss of
rental housing through stratification, redevelopment, or conversion by
other means such as long-term leases.
PURPOSE
This report recommends Council approval of a by-law to permit the
Belmanor Apartments Ltd. to enter into and assign long-term leases.
BACKGROUND
The Belmanor Apartments at 1878 Robson are one of approximately
100 apartment buildings in the City where the units were sold
individually prior to the creation of the Condominium Act. These
buildings are either co-operatives or companies where the units were
sold by way of long term, usually 99-year, leases. The Condominium Act
was introduced to regularize the ownership of multiple residential
buildings, and since its introduction in 1967 few new 'apartment
companies have been developed.
To ensure that rental buildings were not converted to long-term lease
without the municipal approvals required for conversions to
condominiums, the Province in 1990 amended the Residential Tenancy Act
to require municipal approval of the creation and assignment of leases
where the term exceeds 20 years.
Last year the Belmanor Apartments Limited, comprised of 14 units that
were sold by way of long-term lease in 1950, sought the City s
permission to enter into a long-term lease of the caretaker suite for
which a long-term lease had never been created. The owners were using a
management company to maintain the building and had no need for a
caretaker. They wanted to sell the unit and use the proceeds for some
major maintenance projects. The owners intended to sell the caretaker
suite, a small studio unit, to the owner of the adjacent suite who would
consolidate it with theirs.
On July 27, 1995, Council approved the recommendation:
THAT Council, in accordance with Section 2(3) of the
Residential Tenancy Act approve a by-law to permit the
Belmanor Apartments Limited to enter into and assign a long
term lease of the caretaker suite (formerly Apt. #4, now part
of Apt. #5) at 1878 Robson Street and instruct the Director of
Legal Services to prepare the necessary by-law.
Council enacted By-law No. 7486 on November 7, 1995.
DISCUSSION
The owners of the Belmanor Apartments Limited have asked to have the
previous by-law replaced by one that covers the whole building. They
are concerned that the units may be renumbered and recon-figured at some
point in the future and a by-law that refers to specific suites will not
be applicable. There are no plans registered as in the case of strata
corporations developed under the Condominium Act, and it is difficult to
describe individual suites.
This request is supported. The only concern related to whether any of
the other 14 units had always been rental and whether there would be any
displacement of tenants. The 14 existing units are all owner occupied,
and the owners own the building collectively. Rentals have not been
permitted in the building to date. Consequently, in the interests of
clarity and simplicity, it is recommended that the amendments to By-law
No. 6774, which were enacted by By-law No. 7486, be deleted and replaced
with a general by-law that will allow the Belmanor Apartments Limited to
enter into and assign long-term leases in the building at 1878 Robson
Street. As well, if any rentals are approved in the future, a by-law
covering the whole building will allow the assignment (sale) of a unit
to new owner with the tenant in place. Otherwise, a separate new by-law
would be required.
* * * * *