I
REPORT TO COUNCIL
VANCOUVER ATHLETIC COMMISSION
May 21, 1996
RECOMMENDATION
1. Extreme Combat Events in Vancouver
The Vancouver Athletic Commission met on May 21, 1996 to discuss
the circumstances surrounding the recent Extreme Combat Event which was
originally scheduled for the PNE in mid-May, prior to being cancelled.
The Commission wishes to go on record as not supporting Extreme
Combat Events, or any other events of a similar nature, in Vancouver or
anywhere in British Columbia. The recent event would not have been
approved if it had come before the Commission. However, in this
instance, the applicant stated the event was amateur in nature, and
therefore did not fall within the jurisdiction of the Athletic
Commission, which governs professional boxing and wrestling only.
In order to prevent this type of situation from arising again, the
Commission believes that the City should ban extreme fighting. The
appropriate mechanism for achieving this would be through a City by-Law.
2. Provincial Regulation of Boxing, Kickboxing and Wrestling
For several years now, the Vancouver Athletic Commission has held
the view that the regulation of professional boxing, kickboxing and
wrestling should be administered at a Provincial, rather than Municipal
level. This has led to the rather unusual situation where the
Commission has asked that it be disbanded and its role assumed by
Provincial authorities.
The problem which exists is that not all municipalities actually
govern these activities. In Vancouver, where the Athletic Commission
has existed since 1945, we have strict rules pertaining to boxing. For
example, we require boxers to have updated medical passports, and we
meet with, and monitor promoters to ensure they are operating in a
professional fashion. It is not uncommon for the Commission to refuse
to license promoters, or to refuse to license events which do not
meet our standards and operating procedures. Unfortunately, we have
seen a regular and consistent pattern where these events end up in
neighbouring municipalities, which do not have Athletic Commissions, and
do not exercise regulatory control.
The Commission believes that the only solution to this problem is
to have the Province assume jurisdiction over professional boxing,
kickboxing and wrestling. This solution is in keeping with the
recommendations of the National Task Force on Boxing, which recommended
this course of action in 1981.
The City has written to the Province on two occasions with this
request. A copy of the most recent correspondence in March 1995, from
Mayor Owen to the Minister of Municipal Affairs, and the Minister's
response, are attached as Appendix A. In her response, the Minister of
Municipal Affairs advised the Province does not regulate sports, with
the exception of horse racing.
The recent circumstances surrounding the Extreme Combat event lends
further credence to the view of the Athletic Commission that Provincial
regulation is required in this field. The Commission believes this
event could likely have proceeded if it had been staged in a
municipality other than Vancouver.
Attached as Appendix B is a letter to the Union of British Columbia
Municipalities from Mr. Stephen Owen, Deputy Attorney General, advising
the Ministry is willing to work with local municipalities who are
approached by promoters regarding extreme combat events. The Commission
believes this would be an opportune time for the City to once again
request the Province to assume jurisdiction in this area.
Accordingly, the Commission
RECOMMENDS
A. THAT a by-law be brought forward banning the holding of
Extreme Combat types of events in the City of Vancouver.
B. THAT the Mayor write to the appropriate Provincial authorities
requesting the Province to assume authority for the regulation
of professional boxing, kickboxing and wrestling in Vancouver.
(sgd) "Dave Brown"
Dave Brown
Chair, Vancouver Athletic Commission
CITY MANAGER'S COMMENTS
The City Manager RECOMMENDS approval of A and B.