ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
Date: January 25, 1996
Dept. File No.2940E11
TO: Vancouver City Council
FROM: Director of Legal Services and
General Manager Engineering Services
SUBJECT: Renewal of Main Post Office Tunnel Lease
RECOMMENDATION
THAT Council approve a sixty-nine (69) year extension (ending on
December 15, 2055) of the initial thirty (30) year lease to the
Canada Post Corporation of the tunnel from the main CPR station to
the main Post Office.
CITY MANAGER'S COMMENTS
The City Manager RECOMMENDS approval of the foregoing.
COUNCIL POLICY
On May 21, 1957 Council approved a thirty (30) year lease to the Federal
Government to construct and operate a mail transfer tunnel from the CPR
station to the then new Post Office at nominal rent. At the same time,
Council approved seeking an amendment to the Vancouver Charter to permit
Council to grant leases in excess of thirty (30) years to the federal
government without the approval of the electors.
PURPOSE
By this report Council approval is sought for a renewal of the Post
Office tunnel lease for a further sixty-nine (69) years from December
16, 1986 to December 15, 2055.
BACKGROUND
In 1954 the federal Minister of Public Works applied to the City for a
ninety-nine (99) year lease of lands beneath City streets to
construct and operate a mail transfer tunnel from the main CPR station
to the newly to be constructed main Post Office. At that time the mail
came to Vancouver on the CPR railway. As the Vancouver Charter then
read, a lease in excess of thirty (30) years required the assent of the
electors.
Council approved a thirty (30) year lease and directed Corporation
Counsel to seek a Charter amendment to grant leases in excess of thirty
(30) years to the federal government without the assent of the electors.
The thirty (30) year lease with the federal Minister of Public Works was
entered into October 10, 1957.
Shortly after completion of the tunnel, mail began to move by air and so
the tunnel was never used.
- 2 -
The year following the signing of the lease the Vancouver Charter was
changed to allow long term leases to the federal government without the
assent of the electors. Although legally problematical, the expired
lease does provide that if the Vancouver Charter is amended to permit
the ninety-nine (99) year without the assent of the electors, then the
City will grant an extension of the lease for a further sixty-nine (69)
years at nominal rent.
The proposal is to carry through on that commitment and in any event
Canada Post Corporation (an agent of the Federal Crown) says it does not
have the money to restore the tunnel which would cost approximately four
hundred and forty thousand ($440,000.00) dollars.
DISCUSSION
Some economic or utility use for the tunnel may materialize. The
Renewal Lease has the new term that if a viable commercial or utility
use does materialize, the City and the Post Office will negotiate terms
and conditions and sharing benefits of such use. Nevertheless, Canada
Post is obliged to restore the street at the end of the proposed sixty-
nine (69) year extension. Until that time, Canada Post must keep the
tunnel in good repair to support the streets. At this time, the tunnel
is in good condition.
SUMMARY
The proposed lease extension is as the parties originally contemplated.
It makes good sense to wait and see if an economic or utility use can be
made of the tunnel. Council approval of the lease extension is now
sought.
* * * * *