Vancouver City Council |
CITY OF VANCOUVER
ADMINISTRATIVE REPORT
Date:
July 13, 2004
Author:
B. Newson
Phone No.:
871 6002
RTS No.:
4305
CC File No.:
3130
Meeting Date:
July 20, 2004
TO:
Vancouver City Council
FROM:
Director, Office of Cultural Affairs
SUBJECT:
2004 Public Art Project Allocations from Capital
RECOMMENDATION
A. THAT City Council approve $335,000 in allocations to new and current projects from the Public Art Unallocated account as follows:
1. $75,000 for the 2004 Community Public Art Program, with specific projects and budgets reported back for Council's consideration at a later date;
2. $100,000 for local First Nations artwork at Brockton Point;
3. $60,000 to complete the public art plan at the National Works Yard;
4. $30,000 to complete the Ridgeway East Greenway public art process;
5. $15,000 for the Victory Square Mosaic project;
6. $20,000 for public art communications, including pamphlets, brochures, and an instructional video for use in the community public art process;
7. $35,000 in project management funds to aid implementation of the above projects.
B. THAT City Council reallocate $75,000 of $100,000, previously approved for artwork on the Trans Canada Trail to the Public Art Unallocated budget.
Sources of funds are the $250,000 from Basic Capital Budget for Public Art; $75,000 reallocated from the Trans Canada Trail project (RECOMMENDATION B); and $10,000 unallocated funding from previous closed out public art accounts.
GENERAL MANAGER'S COMMENTS
The General Manager RECOMMENDS approval of A.1 through A.7 and B.
COUNCIL POLICY
City Council adopted the Public Art Program for Civic and Private Development in 1990. A
Community Public Art Program was adopted in 1994.City Council provided $750,000 for public art in the 2003-2005 Capital Plan. On May 20, 2004, Council approved $250,000 for 2004 civic public art projects, including this year's Community Public Art Program.
In 1994, Council adopted a policy by which all public art project budgets sited on City lands provide a minimum 10% of project budgets to the Public Art Maintenance Reserve. Interest earned on Reserve funds pays for ongoing public at maintenance.
SUMMARY
This report recommends allocations to public art projects totalling $335,000, including $75,000 for Community Public Art; $100,000 for local First Nations artwork at Brockton Point; $60,000 to complete artwork at the new National Works Yard; $30,000 to complete artwork on the Ridgeway East Greenway; $15,000 for mosaic artwork at Victory Square; $20,000 for program communications; and $35,000 for project management and administration.
PURPOSE
This report recommends allocations to the 2004 Community public Art Program and to public art projects undertaken in association with Park Board, Social Planning, and Engineering Services.
BACKGROUND
The Public Art Program has three components: Civic, Community, and Private Sector. Civic public art processes develop artworks at new and existing City and Parks capital projects. The Community Public Art Program develops public art in neighbourhoods by means of artist and community collaborations. Both the Civic and Community Public Art Programs are funded through the Capital Plan. The Private Sector Program provides options and guidelines for developer-sponsored public art, when art is required as a condition of development.
2004 RECOMMENDED PROJECT ALLOCATIONS
1. Community Public Art: $75,000
The Community Public Art Program offers grants to nonprofit groups which sponsor artist-community collaborations. Projects typically address neighbourhood needs and aspirations, while fostering community pride, identity, and cohesion. This year, as in previous years, project applications will be reviewed and recommended by a panel consisting of staff and community members. Following this review, recommended projects will be presented to Council for consideration.
2. First Nations Brockton Point Artwork: $100,000
Council last year approved $60,000 for a public art process undertaken in consultation with Social Planning that focussed on Vancouver sites having significance to aboriginal people. The intent was to identify such sites through a consultation process and create artworks appropriate to individual site conditions.
Extensive consultations followed with urban aboriginal and local First Nation peoples, who in the process of identifying many sites gave priority over all others to Brockton Point. Indeed, Squamish, Musqueam, and Tsleil' watuth representatives point out that none of the artwork at this famous destination represents local, or indeed any, Coast Salish peoples. Park Board staff have long noted this deficiency and readily agree to incorporate Coast Salish work into the site.
The totems at Brockton Point are among the finest extant. We estimate comparable artwork by local First Nations will cost between $100,000 and $150,000. If the present allocation is approved, it would be added to $60,000 approved last year so artwork of comparable quality can be commissioned.
The prospect of adding Coast Salish artwork to Brockton Point is a positive outcome of this highly cooperative consultation process with urban aboriginal and local First Nation peoples. But we also wish to address the promise of the other sites uncovered through this process. They offer the public a wealth of interpretive information about aboriginal Vancouver, which Native artists, employing the traditional and contemporary practices, could weave into the fabric of the city. Accordingly, we anticipate future requests to Council for this work, once any funds remaining from the Brockton Point process have been allocated to these other sites.
3. National Works Yard: $60,000
Council approved $150,000 for public art at the new Yard in 2002. A Public Art Plan created in close consultation with Engineering Services was approved by the Public Art Committee, and a number of artworks were created: a photographic project by yards staff documenting the transition from the old Yards to the new; substantial works at the southeast and southwest corner of the site; and a photographic collage screening glass doors in the administration building. City staff at all levels participated closely at all stages of this process, a model of its kind.
Intentionally, all artworks to date relate to the purpose and function of City Streets, Traffic, Sewer, or Electrical operations. The final project we propose would look beyond the staff and patrons of the Yard, and have as its primary audience the community of Strathcona, especially those living or traveling along Atlantic Avenue. These residents were the most involved in the development permit process for the Yard, and are most affected by the new development. They currently look down on a large, blank, east-facing, Works Yard wall.
Consultations on this project have begun with yards staff and residents. Fortunately, the first-phase projects at the Yards raised so much interest that the attention of many senior Vancouver artists has been engaged. An artwork budget of $40,000 is requested, and an additional $20,000*, equalling 10.5% of the total value of all artwork at the yards, is requested for the Public Art Maintenance Reserve. This allocation will complete the public art process at the National Works Yard.
4. Ridgeway East Greenway: $30,000
Public art has been featured on the Ridgeway (37th Avenue) Greenway since its inception in the mid 1990s, and sixteen artworks have been completed. Council in 2001 approved $115,000 for the Ridgeway East extension (Knight St. to Central Park in Burnaby), and of three works selected for that route, the first is complete, the second will be installed in September, and the third is scheduled to be completed by 2005.
Of the present request, $15,000 will pay for additional artwork at the 41st and Killarney Ridgeway site, and $15,000, equalling 11.5% of the total budget for all three Ridgeway East artworks, will be allocated to the Public Art Maintenance Reserve. This allocation will complete the current public art process on the Ridgeway East Greenway. No artwork was been commissioned for the Ridgeway from Granville to the Endowment Lands, and we will report on that process at a later date.
5. Victory Square Mosaic Project: $15,000
Park Board in recent years has made changes to Victory Square to improve the physical layout, social conditions, and appearance of this highly significant and historic public place. The recent creation of a small stage at the east side of the park affords an opportunity to combine social and artistic objectives. Working under the guidance of a skilled artist, persons in the downtown east side would be organised through Carnegie Centre in the development of a mosaic that would be installed on the stage. The project is supported by Park Board, Carnegie Centre, Friends of Victory Square, and others involved in the redevelopment of Victory Square.
6. Public Art Communications: $20,000
Public art processes require extensive public consultation and the production of printed notices, pamphlets, brochures, advertisements, documentary packages, guides, and the like. This year, we wish to commission an instructional video to inform artists and community partners who are preparing to undertake a Community Public Art process. The estimated cost of $4,000 to $5,000 will more than be saved through a reduction in the staff time needed to provide this service. This request will provide the video and fund the other materials above.
7. Project management and Administration: $35,000.
Civic public art processes are implemented by contract consultants who manage projects and perform a variety of project-related administrative duties at the direction of staff. Depending on the complexity and the degree of public consultation required, Individual projects vary greatly in the amount of consultant time required. The budget also covers unanticipated costs, such as the manhole cover public art process initiated last spring.
By policy, City and Private Sector projects are managed at a cost no greater than 20% of the artwork budget, despite the extensive community consultations the City process requires. The requested $35,000 equals just over 14% of the $245,000 new art projects budgets requested above (art project budgets minus maintenance funds, and not including the communications request of $20,000).
RECOMMENDATION B
Reallocation of Trans Canada Trail Funding
Council previously approved $100,000 for artwork at the Vancouver entrance to the Trans Canada Trail, just east of Iron Workers Memorial Bridge. The earlier request assumed that the inherent richness of the site-a rare combination of engineering marvels and great natural beauty-required a "place-making" art process, likely leading to the production of a viewing platform or possibly a combined trains-spotting/general observation tower. However, some judicious pruning has enabled the new Trail bridge over the rail tunnel to perform these functions, and opened up stunning views in most directions. The impetus for the earlier public art process is gone.
After extensive consultation with the Public Art Committee, staff recommend a reduction of the original budget to $25,000, enabling a more modest project that focuses on other aspects of the Trail, and the reallocation of the balance ($75,000) to other projects above.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS
SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDED PROJECTS AND BUDGETS | |
Funds Available: |
|
Reallocated from Trans Canada Trail |
75,000 |
Allocated from previously closed out accounts |
10,000 |
2004 Capital Budget |
250,000 |
Total |
335,000 |
Projects Recommended: |
|
Community Public Art |
75,000 |
Brockton Point Local First Nations |
100,000 |
National Works Yard Completion |
60,000 |
Ridgeway East Completion |
30,000 |
Victory Square mosaic |
15,000 |
Communications |
20,000 |
Project Management |
35,000 |
Total |
335,000 |
Other significant public art processes and projects are underway, and major opportunities are anticipated in the next capital plan and the upcoming Olympics. Staff intend to undertake a 10-year review of the public art program, and will report on it and these other projects and opportunities at a later date.
CONCLUSION
The Director of Cultural Affairs recommends allocations totalling $335,000 to public art processes as follows: $75,000 to the 2004 Community Public Art Program; $100,000 for artwork by Local First Nations at Brockton Point; $60,000 to complete the public art process at National Works Yards; $30,000 to complete the public art process at the East Ridgeway Greenway; $15,000 for a mosaic project at Victory Square; $20,000 for Program communications; and $35,000 for project management.
* * * * *